Home > Reviews > LION – Dustin O’Halloran and Volker Bertelmann

LION – Dustin O’Halloran and Volker Bertelmann

January 30, 2017 Leave a comment Go to comments

lionOriginal Review by Jonathan Broxton

Director Garth Davis’s film Lion is a warm-hearted real life drama based on the non-fiction book A Long Way Home by Saroo Brierley and Larry Buttrose, which stars Dev Patel as a young Indian-Australian man caught between two cultures. As a child in rural India, 5-year old Saroo (Sunny Pawar) and his older brother Guddu (Abhishek Bharate) eke out a meager living, finding and selling rocks and cleaning trains. One day, Saroo accidentally finds himself stuck on a train bound for Calcutta; completely alone in a megalopolis of almost 15 million people, and with no way home, Saroo lives among the city’s homeless children until he is eventually taken in by an orphanage, who arrange for him to be adopted by an Australian couple, Sue and John Brierley (Nicole Kidman and David Wenham). Twenty years later, the adult Saroo has forgotten much of the detail about his childhood, but gradually becomes obsessed with finding his birth parents, spending all his time feverishly searching Google Earth, and alienating his girlfriend Lucy (Rooney Mara). What emerges is a moving story about cultural identity, family, and the strength and dedication Saroo shows in trying to discover the truth about his past.

Lion has been roundly praised by the majority of mainstream film critics, mostly for the emotional performances of Patel and Pawar as Saroo, and for the sterling support provided by Nicole Kidman as the kind-hearted, patient adoptive mother. Also receiving strong critical praise is the score, written by Dustin O’Halloran and Volker Bertelmann. O’Halloran is an American composer, musician, and pianist, whose most prominent work to date has been on the acclaimed TV show Transparent, for which he won the Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Main Title Theme Music in 2015. Bertelmann, who uses the professional alias Hauschka, is a German classical pianist and composer who specializes in work for a prepared piano; he has been writing for documentaries and short films since 2007, but Lion is his first score with any significant international commercial appeal.

By and large, the score for Lion is quite undemanding, and comprises mainly a series of light classical pieces for strings, piano, and synths, with occasional color and flavor from harp, guitar, and light metallic percussion. The score is built around a main theme, the “Lion Theme,” which is introduced in the eponymous second cue. It’s less of an actual melody than it is a simple, agreeable, undulating texture; it is first heard on piano, backed by a light stringwash, but later in the score the composers shift the melody to different instruments: harp augmented by gentle metallic percussion in “River,” back to piano with a soft, contemplative aspect in “Orphans” and the subsequent “Family,” and so on.

The majority of the other cues build upon the same general stylistics of the main theme, but offer a few subtle variations in tempo and orchestration. The most notable of these include “Train,” which uses lonely, haunted sounding drones overlapped by more agitated, panicky string phrases to capture Saroo’s increasing sense of desperation as he is unwittingly removed from his home; “Escape the Station,” which uses darker piano clusters and scratchy, urgent string writing to underscore the young boy’s frantic flight from the authorities at Howrah Junction Station; “A New Home,” which makes use of curious, magical sounding pianos; and “Falling Downward,” a collision of harsh synth tones and rhapsodic, classical piano flourishes that try to get inside adult Saroo’s state of mind.

The final three cues offer what should be the film’s emotional catharsis but, oddly, O’Halloran and Bertelmann refrain from doing this fully; their only concession to the images of Saroo realizing his life’s dream is to incorporate some slightly warmer, major key string harmonics into the familiar palette from the rest of the score. Nevertheless, these cues are certainly attractive, albeit in a rather understated way. “Home Is With Me” features a performance of the Lion theme on one of Bertelmann’s famous muffled prepared pianos, which gradually grows to include the aforementioned warm violin chords, while “Arrival” and “Mother” are generally soft and poignant. It is something of an odd reversal of expectation in that, the closer Saroo gets to his destination and goal – being reunited with his birth mother – the less emotional the score gets, but that appears to be way of things in film music these days. God forbid a score actually make an audience feel something.

One other point to mention is that, with the exception of a few brief synth tones which have a vague resemblance to the underpinning drone of a raga, there is a complete lack of anything that references traditional Indian music anywhere in the score, which is puzzling and disappointing considering how much emphasis the film places on connecting with your roots and embracing your cultural identity. In fact, the only concession to anything remotely Indian comes in the original song “Never Give Up” by Sia, which appears to use a sitar and a santoor dulcimer in its opening moments, and features tabla percussion throughout the rest of the song’s more pop-oriented core.

I have a friend – a fellow IFMCA member, from Spain – who calls this music ‘gondolier music,’ and he’s absolutely right in his description; it just sort of drifts past serenely, inoffensive and gentle but leaving no lasting impression. It neither adds to nor detracts from the film going experience, and instead just sits on top of the movie like a layer of haze, an innocuous dreamlike ambiance of no real substance. And, really, this is my major criticism of Lion: there’s no depth to it. There’s nothing wrong with it, compositionally speaking, and it’s pleasant enough to listen to as a standalone piece of music, but its so understated and careful, so safe and restrained, and takes so many pains to avoid being manipulative, that it renders itself redundant. The film would be just the same, and would have just the same emotional impact on its audience, if there was no music there at all, which could actually be the worst criticism you can level against a film composer: if the music you’re writing isn’t making your film better, what are you actually achieving? It’s a question to ponder as, inevitably, O’Halloran and Bertelmann accept their first Academy Award nominations.

Buy the Lion soundtrack from the Movie Music UK Store

Track Listing:

  • Never Give Up (written by Sia Furler and Greg Kurstin, performed by Sia) (3:41)
  • Lion Theme (1:58)
  • Train (1:38)
  • Lost, Part 1 (3:06)
  • River (1:27)
  • Escape the Station (2:25)
  • Orphans (1:37)
  • A New Home (1:54)
  • Family (1:04)
  • School (0:38)
  • Memories (1:52)
  • Lost, Part 2 (2:31)
  • Falling Downward (3:05)
  • Searching for Home (2:16)
  • Memory/Connection/Time (1:40)
  • Layers Expanding Time (5:31)
  • Home Is With Me (3:15)
  • Arrival (4:26)
  • Mother (4:28)

Running Time: 48 minutes 43 seconds

Sony Classical (2016)

Music composed and arranged by Dustin O’Halloran and Volker Bertelmann. Recorded and mixed by Jeremy Underwood and Satoshi Mark Noguchi. Edited by Tim Ryan. Album produced by Dustin O’Halloran and Volker Bertelmann.

  1. Michael
    January 31, 2017 at 8:04 pm

    “God forbid a score actually make an audience feel something.” Saw the movie today and I did felt something during the whole time the music came. It played out the elements of sadness, dispair, calmness and darkness that the movie gave. And during the climax of the film, the music reflected the relief of Saroo finally founding his mother but at the same time the tragedy of him discovering that his brother died. There wasn’t a single time where the score didn’t felt emotional.

    Independent of how these scores are made, seems like you want to bash them just because they are nominated (other than Lalaland because you like the rest knows that the score is gonna win and it’s better to complain about the others).. And at the same time, and ironically, you are bashing orchestral scores with actual melodies, while the Academy had nominated and awarded scores with less type of melodies than these.

    Sometimes the best scores aren’t the ones with a 10.000 piece orchestra and 100 hours of music with thousand of themes. The best scores are the ones that do the necessary job, whetever they are only 5 or 50 minutes long, or they’re played by a full orchestra or a simple violin solo or electronics.

    • Aidabaida
      February 1, 2017 at 9:40 am

      I agree with you Michael. Sometimes, subtle scores are what make the biggest difference. Music is intended primarily to serve the movie, not the listener, and that’s not always going to be interesting to listen to.

  2. vassilis
    February 2, 2017 at 6:30 am

    The score is not complex and actually doesn’t have a particularly memorable melody as a main theme, but its idea is certain and is linked with the character of Sheru and his emotions during the mishaps and adventures of his life. The music is edited very carefully in the movie and its structure serves the movie’s perspective in a very subtle but effective manner , especially in the final act when Sheru finds his relatives after 25 years (low key piano chords that restrain the overflowing emotion)..

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: