Home > Reviews > PROMETHEUS – Marc Streitenfeld

PROMETHEUS – Marc Streitenfeld

Original Review by Jonathan Broxton

Prometheus sees the eagerly-awaited and highly anticipated return to the Alien franchise of director Ridley Scott, whose groundbreaking science fiction films in the late 1970s and early 80s help shaped the genre as we know it today. While not a direct prequel to his 1979 masterpiece, the film does take place before the events of that classic film, and within the same general universe. However, whereas the original Alien was essentially a haunted house movie in space, Prometheus asks bigger questions about the meaning – and origins – of life itself. Noomi Rapace and and Logan Marshall-Green star as a pair of scientists who, via some ancient cave paintings, discover a “star map” which they think will lead them across the universe to where life on Earth began. Years later, the pair arrive on a distant planet with a cadre of associates funded by the Weyland corporation: icy administrator Charlize Theron, ship’s captain Idris Elba, geologist Rafe Spall, biologist Sean Harris, plus a sentient android named David, played with clinical conviction by Michael Fassbender. However, upon their arrival and initial forays onto the planet, the team find much more than they anticipated, and a great deal of danger.

The Alien franchise has a storied and impressive musical heritage, from Jerry Goldsmith on the original Alien, through James Horner on Aliens, Elliot Goldenthal on Alien 3, and John Frizzell on Alien Resurrection, as well as Brian Tyler and Harald Kloser on the Alien-Predator crossovers. It must have been a daunting task for German composer Marc Streitenfeld to step into this arena, not only with the weight of previous composers to consider, but with the added pressure of Prometheus being one of the most highly anticipated films in years. Having only scored seven films since making his debut in 2006, there was really nothing in his filmography to suggest that he had the composing chops necessary to step up to the task, and unfortunately this proves to be true. His score is a murky, surprisingly pedestrian orchestral/electronic hybrid which clearly tries to pick up the mantle of his predecessors, but has nowhere near the technical or compositional excellence that Goldsmith, Horner and Goldenthal brought to their orchestral/electronic hybrids.

In fact, it seems that Streitenfeld’s music actually suffered a similar fate to that of his peers. It is well-known that at least three of the prior composers had terrible experiences writing their Alien scores: Ridley Scott replaced much of Jerry Goldsmith’s score with classical pieces and re-arranged the rest out of sequence; James Horner and James Cameron almost came to blows on the scoring stage of Aliens, and Elliot Goldenthal suffered so much studio interference that his Alien 3 score was altered beyond recognition in the final cut. Streitenfeld’s ignominy is in having the bulk of his thematic material replaced with music by Harry Gregson-Williams in the finished picture; Gregson-Williams’ “Life” theme is by far the standout musical element in the film, and features at least half a dozen times during some of the movie’s most pivotal moments. The theme – which features on the soundtrack album in “Life” and “We Were Right” – is a noble, optimistic melody for horns and strings augmented by a light choral element, and is quite beautiful, although its use in context seems rather muddled: it’s almost as though Scott, realizing his movie didn’t have a strong musical identity, simply stuck Gregson-Williams’s theme in wherever he felt the need for a memorable musical moment, irrespective of what the scene was or whether the use of that theme at that moment actually made narrative sense. Nevertheless, the theme is lovely, and will undoubtedly go on to become the most remembered musical aspect of the film.

The rest of Streitenfeld’s score is a surprisingly uninvolving affair, and despite the presence of three new themes and a couple of smaller motifs and recurring performance techniques, it never really lingers long in the memory or generates much of an individual identity. There’s a suitably large orchestra, and a whole bank of synthesizers and electronic textures to add otherworldly ambiences, but on the whole it fails to truly establish itself beyond its own narrow scope, instead content to mirror the action with creepy vignettes of suspense and a couple of explosions of noise for the action sequences.

A main theme of sorts is heard in the opening “A Planet”, and crops up again in later cues such as “Small Beginnings”, “Dazed” and “Collision”; it shares some of the same harmonic language as Gregson-Williams’s theme, with the two almost seeming to merge together in cues such as the rather impressive “Earth”, but in context it fades into the background whenever the “Life” theme comes to the fore, making it seem curiously unresolved and understated. A see-sawing four-note danger motif (not like Horner’s) appears in “Going In”, “Not Human”, “Too Close”, “Hyper Sleep”, and several other cues to represent the unknown but omnipresent threats facing the crew of the Prometheus, although the instrumentation and layers of sound accompanying the motif tend to make it difficult to identify. Often, Streitenfeld uses what sounds like a processed bass flute to bring this motif to life, which lends the score an unexpected 1970s flavor, before the grinding synthesizers and other industrial groans and moans quickly bring it back into the present.

In some cues, notably “David”, Streitenfeld manipulates his music to give it an abstract, oddly detached feeling, which he achieved by having his orchestra play the music backwards and reversing the sound in post-production. Also in this cue, and in cues such as “Small Beginnings”, there’s a staccato pulse beating under the music, a little like a mechanical heartbeat, but which Streitenfeld describes as ‘the sound of blood rushing through your ears’, which acts as something of a recurring tone to represent David’s synthetic nature. Elsewhere, the music establishes a rhythmic undercurrent to give the score a sense of forward motion, whereupon Streitenfeld layers on various blocks of dissonant orchestral noise, adopting a “wall of sound” approach to overwhelm listeners during action scenes. Cues such as “Hammerpede”, the opening parts of “Infected”, “Hello Mommy”, “Dazed” and “Planting the Seed” adopt this style, which is effective enough, but seems more than a little overly-familiar.

A large-scale final theme, which seems to musically represent the God-like power employed by the Engineers, is first performed on noble brasses in the opening cue “A Planet”, and appears again as a leitmotif for the Final Engineer in the powerful “Space Jockey, the noble and resilient “Collision” and the conclusive “Birth”. One final conceit is a processed restatement of Jerry Goldsmith’s original theme for Alien in “Friend from the Past”, which underscores a pivotal scene of exposition and is a nice nod and a wink to the old master. The majority of film-goers won’t even notice it, but I liked the tribute.

As much as Prometheus works well enough in context, Streitenfeld’s work on this score really doesn’t live up to its pre-release hype, and will not be remembered as well as any of the others in the pantheon of Alien scores. As much as I don’t like questioning a composer’s credentials, I do have to wonder whether hiring a comparatively green composer like Streitenfeld was a wise idea for a film of this magnitude; it’s likely that the assignment was simply too big for him, and having heard his small contribution, one can’t help but wonder what Harry Gregson-Williams or someone like him would have done with a canvas like this. It’s a shame; much like the film it accompanies, it promised much, but delivers less.

Rating: **½

Buy the Prometheus soundtrack from the Movie Music UK Store

Track Listing:

  • A Planet (2:37)
  • Going In (2:03)
  • Engineers (2:29)
  • Life (2:30)
  • Weyland (2:04)
  • Discovery (2:32)
  • Not Human (1:49)
  • Too Close (3:20)
  • Try Harder (2:03)
  • David (3:00)
  • Hammerpede (2:42)
  • We Were Right (2:42)
  • Earth (2:35)
  • Infected (1:56)
  • Hyper Sleep (2:01)
  • Small Beginnings (2:11)
  • Hello Mommy (2:04)
  • Friend From the Past (1:14)
  • Dazed (4:29)
  • Space Jockey (1:29)
  • Collision (3:05)
  • Debris (0:44)
  • Planting the Seed (1:35)
  • Invitation (2:16)
  • Birth (1:24)

Running Time: 56 minutes 55 seconds

Sony Classical 88691978342 (2012)

Music composed by Marc Streitenfeld. Conducted and orchestrated by Ben Foster. Additional music by Harry Gregson-Williams. Theme from Alien by Jerry Goldsmith. Recorded and mixed by Peter Cobbin. Edited by Kirsty Whalley, Del Spiva and Joseph Bonn. Album produced by Marc Streitenfeld.

About these ads
  1. June 21, 2012 at 3:08 am

    I don’t get Scott’s loyalty to Streitenfeld, aside from perhaps the fact that his music is so simplistic that it’s easy to chop up and rearrange. Even when he clearly put in a lot of effort his music is effortlessly upstaged by HGW’s additional music; one wishes Scott had given the latter the whole assignment.

  2. June 21, 2012 at 7:29 am

    I actually enjoyed both, the score and the film. I think that Streitenfeld is a promising composer. His score for The Grey also proves it. He seems to have a clear idea when using motifs for certain characters or situations -the repetitive four note theme in Prometheus and the deep bass sax effect for the wolves in The Grey. They may still sound unpolished in the final CD product but they still cause an impression in the pictures. Gregson-Williams’ contribution to this score is significant, and his signature is evident in the tracks that appear in the album. But this duo-team of composers have proven to be able to produce magnificent music. Scott’s Kingdom of Heaven is a wonderful score, though some may disagree.
    Scott is known among film music enthusiasts to be a director that has always had a somewhat twisted approach to the scores of his films. But I believe that Prometheus stands out as a score that has its own voice, regardless of the clichèd action scenes. The pulsing rhythm that is heard in tracks such as “Going In” and “Too Close” works perfectly within the film. I’ve also found that tracks as “A Planet”, the beginning of “Space Jockey”, “Collision” and “Invitation” are quite emotional, and contribute to memorable sequences of the film. I believe that this is a solid 3-star score and that Streitenfeld is one of the most promising composers that the Remote Control group has produced in the recent years. I don’t know about you, but throughout his scores I’ve been able to notice his own particular style and it is quite evident that it doesn’t sound as Zimmer’s style.

  3. PT
    June 21, 2012 at 11:28 am

    Good, well thought-out review as ever. On this rare ocassions I do not entirely agree with you though. Personally I very much enjoyed the score. It has its flaws, but overall I think it’s a pretty good (or if one must: a surprisingly good) effort.
    I think Marc’s themes are pretty strong. The theme is so epically portrayed in Space Jockey and Collision is frequently running round my head.
    I don’t think the synthesizer parts deserve such a quick dismissal. It sound like a lot of thought has gone into the programming and the sound design. I found the synths parts to have a eerie organic feel to them. Like a distorted reality. I found it very well done and very fitting. (A bit like how Isham’s Crash is (almost) entirely synthesised, yet sounds so organic).
    I’m surprised you didn’t mention that the see-sawing (processed) flute motif is clearly a take-off from the original echoing flute motif in Alien (I think it was referred to as a ‘time’ motif…?). And it’s that motif that really ties it into the Alien franchise.
    I do agree that the action material is somewhat weak. The orchestral dissonance clearly trying to evoke a Goldenthalian sound, but not being very good at it. Also, the sequencing on CD is a bit odd, especially with the album ending rather……….. (exactly, like that).
    In relation to your “underdeveloped themes” comment, I wonder whether Marc actually wrote anything for those scenes that ended up with HGW’s music? Wondering whether Marc never even scored those scenes, or whether he did but got replaced?
    Also… who wrote the track Earth? That’s clearly HGW’s theme in there.
    Generally, it’s unfortunate and somewhat unfair (if expected) that it gets compared to Goldsmith’s, Horner’s and Goldenthal’s scores. Of course it’s never going to be that good. Heck, their scores are (amongst) the best of their respective careers. If instead you compare it to the average current blockbuster score, Prometheus is considerably more interesting (if still flawed). ***1/2 from me.

    • A. Rubinstein
      June 26, 2012 at 12:33 am

      “their scores are (amongst) the best of their respective careers”?
      Not really. I wouldn’t place neither Alien nor Aliens in Goldsmith’s/Horner’s top 20, maybe even top 30 scores. And yet they’re still miles ahead of what Streitenfeld wrote for Prometheus.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 560 other followers